Will Closed Bidding in Place of E-Reverse Auctions Boost the Indian Wind Sector?

The government intends to pull the plug on e-reverse auctions

July 27, 2022

/ Wind
thumbnail

Five years after it was introduced, the government has decided to consider alternative options for e-reverse auctions following complaints from the industry that it is leading to unviable tariffs due to unhealthy competition.

The announcement to phase out e-reverse auctions was made by the Secretary, Ministry of New & Renewable Energy (MNRE), Indu Shekhar Chaturvedi, at a conference recently.

The e-reverse auction was introduced to promote competition. However, aggressive bids have led to lower profit margins, sometimes to the point where the winning bid is unviable.

What went wrong with e-reverse auctions? If the government intends to do away with the auctions, what is the way forward? Mercom spoke with representatives of the wind energy sector for their views on these issues.

According to Manish K. Singh, Secretary General, Indian Wind Energy Association, the e-reverse auctions for wind projects introduced in 2017 spawned unhealthy competition to win bids. “The low tariffs at which these bids were won had no relationship with the estimated costs. A few ventures or companies wanting to be IPPs bid very low rates to win the projects in the hope that costs could be managed. It created a situation where the tariffs were not sustainable, leading to the non-completion of projects.”

The annual installed wind capacity plummeted from 5.4 GW in 2016-17 to 1.2 GW to 2 GW in subsequent years. Wind power tariffs dropped to a record-low of ₹2.43 (~$0.030)/kWh in the GUVNL 500 MW auction held in December 2017. This was lower than the lowest solar tariff of ₹2.44 (~$0.031)/kWh quoted in the Bhadla Solar auction in May 2017.

During the last five years, the Solar Energy Corporation of India (SECI) has auctioned around 16 GW of wind projects but awarded only around 12.5 GW of capacity.

“Bidders did not show any interest in 3,500 MW of projects. Out of 12,500 MW auctioned projects, only around 3,000 MW of projects have achieved closure,” Singh said.

Course correction

Kasthurirangaian, Chairman of the Indian Wind Power Association, welcomed the move to scrap the ‘flawed’ reverse auctions. “The allocation of projects at the price points was unviable and unsustainable.”

Singh believes more projects would see fruition going forward. “With realistic prices, the year-over-year capacity additions will go up.” He recalled that India recorded its highest annual addition to wind capacity at 5.5 GW in 2016-17, just before the e-reverse auctions were introduced.

Stakeholders have little doubt that doing away with reverse auctions will bring about stability and avoid speculation. According to D V Giri, Secretary General, Indian Wind Turbine Manufacturers Association, eligibility conditions for bidders will infuse more seriousness and lead to sustainable tariffs.

But will scrapping e-reverse auctions alone see the end of the unhealthy competition? Singh adds a caveat. “One cannot say with certainty that floor price alone would obviate unhealthy competition. In fact, questions could be raised on the methodology of fixation of the floor price itself. Given the wind potential in various states, cost of land, etc., the floor price could vary from state to state. Since bids are not site-specific, determining a floor price would be a complicated process. It would be better to proceed based on closed bids in large tenders.  Of course, if the bids are called for specific sites, an exercise can be done to fix a floor price.”

Giri maintains that closed bidding is the way to go. “Closed bidding is a well-known practice both in defense and infrastructure projects. The closed bidding should not be based on L1 but on the bucket filing process. Closed bidding should cover a minimum of 5-6 states with a total bid size of 4 GW, and each state will have its own tariff. The tariff will have to be pooled and sold to distribution companies.”

“The last five years have seen capacity addition of 1.5 GW per annum against the target of 10 GW to reach 140 GW by 2030. Many auctioned projects are not implemented due to unviable tariffs or project execution issues. Closed bidding spread across five to six states with identified land and connectivity will ensure timely execution and also give visibility and certainty to the OEMs (original equipment manufacturers), who have now switched over to exports with an uncertain domestic market,” he said.

Kasthurirangaian also supports the closed bidding mode.

“In fiercely competitive e-reverse auctions, because of the low response time limits, bidders quote below the competitors’ bids without any objective assessment of costs. In closed bids, the potential bidders would submit bids based on realistic assumptions of costs, IRR, etc. The temptation to outbid the other bidders would be low. Despite their objective bids, if a company loses the bid, it is their bad luck alone,” Singh said.

In the last few years, the wind industry has not kept pace with its solar counterpart in the renewable industry. While the government has said it wants to end e-reverse auctions, it is yet to make clear what mechanism will replace them. On its part, the wind industry is pitching for the closed bidding route so that the true price of projects is reflected in the bid price. It hopes the government will respond positively to its recommendation.

Subscribe to Mercom’s real-time Regulatory Updates to ensure you don’t miss any critical updates from the renewable industry.

RELATED POSTS

thumbnail
Top 5 States for Open Access Solar Installations in CY 2022

India added an impressive 2.5 GW open access solar capacity in 2022, registering a growth of 92% year-over-year (YoY), according to the 2022 Q4 & Annual Mercom India Solar Open Access Market Report. Karnataka emerged as the to...

March 23, 2023

Markets & Policy

Government Clarifies ALMM Enlistment Guidelines for Co-branded Solar Modules

The Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) has modified the Approved List of Models and Manufacturers (ALMM) guidelines and provided exceptions to broaden the qualification criteria for modules produced under agreements betwe...

March 24, 2023

C&I

In Bengaluru, a 100 kW Solar System Can Save C&I Entities ₹1 Million Annually

Mercom India successfully concluded the C&I Clean Energy Meet 2023 in Bengaluru, where stakeholders in the solar sector and commercial and industrial entities converged to enthusiastically discuss the benefits of renewable ene...

March 24, 2023

Other

Gensol Acquires Solar Tracker Maker Scorpius for ₹1.35 Billion

Gensol Engineering, a part of solar engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) company Gensol Group, has acquired India-based solar tracker manufacturer Scorpius Trackers for ₹1.35 billion ($16.4 million). Gensol said the ac...

March 23, 2023

Magazine

DON'T MISS AN ISSUE!

Mercom Cleantech Magazine

Get Your Copy Today!

magazines

Latest News

thumbnail
Intra-State Sections of Evacuation Infrastructure for Renewables Delayed

The Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) told the Parliamentary Standing Committee on Energy that the intra-state stretches of the Green Energy Corridor (GEC) have been delayed due to various reasons, including...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
EnBW Takes €2.4 Billion Final Investment Decision on Offshore Wind Project

German electric utility company Energie Baden-Wuerttemberg (EnBW) has made its final €2.4 billion (~$2.6 billion) investment decision on He Dreiht, a major wind project in the German North Sea. The project has a capacity of 960...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
India Missed 2022 Renewables Target as Rooftop Solar and Wind fell Short

The Parliamentary Standing Committee on Energy report has isolated underwhelming progress on rooftop solar and wind energy projects as the primary reason for India falling short of achieving its renewable energy capacity target...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
Researchers Aim to Accelerate Delivery of Space-Based Solar Power to Earth

Researchers at Northumbria University are studying ways of producing wireless electricity from space to Earth by harvesting the Sun’s energy. U.S.-based aerospace, defense, and information security organization Lockheed Martin...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
Regulator Directs Wind Energy Firm, MSEDCL, to Recompute Delayed Payment Charge

The Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission (MERC) recently directed Hindustan Petroleum Corporation (HPCL) and the Maharashtra State Electricity Distribution Company (MSEDCL) to recompute the delayed payment charge from...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
One-Step Coating Could Make Perovskite Solar Cells Commercially Viable

The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) has devised a new way to produce perovskite solar cells that could speed its commercialization. Different layers are typically added sequentially to a conductive glass substrate to...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
ACWA Power to Develop Solar and Energy Storage Projects in Uzbekistan

Saudi Arabia-based energy company ACWA Power has signed power purchase and investment agreements with  National Electric Grid of Uzbekistan, and the Ministry of Investment, Industry, and Trade to develop new solar and battery...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
China Securities Regulatory Commission Approves Canadian Solar’s IPO

The China Securities Regulatory Commission has approved the registration of CSI Solar, the engineering, procurement, and construction arm of solar module maker Canadian Solar, to issue an initial public offering (IPO). The...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
Renewables Accounted for 83% of the Total Generation Capacity Added in 2022

Renewable capacity grew by 9.6% in 2022, adding a record 295 GW worldwide. This accounts for 83% of all power capacity added last year and brings the global renewable generation capacity to 3,372 GW by the end of last year, a...

March 24, 2023

thumbnail
Government Clarifies ALMM Enlistment Guidelines for Co-branded Solar Modules

The Ministry of New and Renewable Energy (MNRE) has modified the Approved List of Models and Manufacturers (ALMM) guidelines and provided exceptions to broaden the qualification criteria for modules produced under agreements...

March 24, 2023

MORE NEWS