Arbitration in India-US Solar DCR Case May Extend Beyond 60 Days

Several members have expressed concerns about the absence of a proposed level of retaliation in the US request

thumbnail

The ongoing trade rift between India and the United States over the solar Domestic Content Requirement (DCR) category has been referred to arbitration, but the complexity of the case suggests that negotiations are likely to extend beyond the standard 60-day arbitration period.

An official at the World Trade Organization (WTO) told Mercom, “The time-period for the arbitration fixed under Article 22.6 is very short, and it would not be surprising if the arbitration in this case goes beyond the 60-day period.”

Article 22.6 of the WTO’s Dispute Settlement Understanding states that arbitration must be completed within 60 days from the date of expiry of a reasonable period of time, which was December 14, 2017 in India’s solar case.

The arbitration is set to be carried out either by the original panel or by an arbitrator appointed by the WTO Director-General, the official added.

The move to arbitration comes after India earlier this month strongly disputed US accusations that it had failed to abide by solar policy norms prescribed by the WTO following an earlier dispute over its DCR program. India called the US accusations “groundless.”

“India strongly objects to the suspension of concessions or other obligations under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade 1994 proposed by the US,” the country said in a statement.

The WTO’s Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) had initially sought more clarity from India on whether it was objecting to the level of suspensions proposed by the US. The detail is a technicality that is typically needed before a matter can be sent to arbitration. But since the US had not included a proposed level in its request, there was nothing for India to respond to.

The omission fueled the flames of contention between the two countries and prompted several WTO member countries to express support for India.

“Several members expressed concern about the absence of a proposed level of retaliation in the US request and said such a request should include either the proposed amount of retaliation or a description of the proposed formula; failure to do this adversely affects the rights of the responding member. Others said that there was no need for the DSB to consider the US request as India had already objected to it,” the WTO official added.

Quick Recap

In December 2017, the US requested that the DSB authorize the suspension of concessions or other obligations with India at an annual level based on a formula proportionate to the trade effects caused on US interests by India’s failure to comply.

On January 3, 2018, India submitted a communication in which it objected to the request made by the US.

In its statement, India said it stands severely prejudiced by the vagueness and opaqueness of the US request which contains no indication why the US believes India has not complied with the ruling or the proposed level of suspension the US considers equivalent to the purported harm the Indian measures caused to US trade. India emphasized that if the US had any disagreement with India on compliance, this must first be addressed through compliance panel proceedings under Article 21.5 of the DSU. However, despite repeated requests from India, the US refused to sign a sequencing agreement with India establishing this process, which goes against the standard practice of WTO members acting in good faith.

“However, nowhere in this communication did India state that it objects to the level of suspension proposed by the US, which would automatically trigger arbitration on the amount of retaliation under Article 22.6 of the DSU,” the US noted.

After taking note of the statements made by both the parties, the DSB  referred the dispute between the two countries to arbitration.

“All this adds to more uncertainty about DCR projects in the sector. Hopefully this case is completely resolved and there is clarity and direction from the government on future DCR projects,” said Raj Prabhu, CEO of Mercom Capital Group.

Image credit: WTO

thumbnail

Saumy Prateek

RELATED POSTS

Mercom Research Focus
thumbnail
India Installs a Record 2.5 GW of Solar Open Access in 2022, Up 92% YoY

India added 2.5 GW of solar open access in the calendar year (CY) 2022, a year-over-year (YoY) increase of 92% from the 1.3 GW installed in CY 2021, according to the newly released 2022 Q4 & Annual Mercom India Solar Open Acce...

March 15, 2023

Solar

Kerala Issues Empanelment Tender for 100 MW of Solar Projects

The Kerala State Electricity Board (KSEB) has invited bids to empanel solar developers to set up 100 MW of grid-connected rooftop and ground-mounted projects. Empanelled vendors also must furnish operation and maintenance (O&M...

March 20, 2023

Tenders and Auctions

Gujarat Invites Bids to Procure 500 MW of Wind Power with Greenshoe Option

Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam (GUVNL) has invited bids to procure power from 500 MW of grid-connected wind projects (Phase V) with a greenshoe option of an additional capacity of up to 500 MW. The last day to submit the bids online is ...

March 17, 2023

Rooftop

MSMEs Adopt Solar Readily If Savings on Power Bills Cover EMI Cost: Interview

Small businesses are open to adopting rooftop solar if loan repayment is not an additional burden and is equal to their savings on electricity bills. Entities in the commercial and industrial (C&I) segment are increasingly mov...

March 17, 2023

Magazine

DON'T MISS AN ISSUE!

Mercom Cleantech Magazine

Get Your Copy Today!

magazines

Latest News

thumbnail
Maharashtra Approves Tariffs for 8.7 MW of Solar Power Under KUSUM Program

The Maharashtra Electricity Regulatory Commission (MERC) has adopted tariffs of ₹3.28 (~$0.039)/kWh, ₹3.29 (~$0.039)/kWh, and ₹3.30 (~$0.040)/kWh for the procurement of 8.7 MW of solar power on a long-term basis. The Commission...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
Brookfield to Aquire KKR’s 50% Stake in Renewable Developer X-Elio

Global investment firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR) has agreed to sell 50% of its stake in renewable developer X-ELIO to its joint venture partner Brookfield Renewable. Financial details were not disclosed. Since KKR’s...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
NTPC’s Subsidiary Will Develop Renewable Projects for IndianOil Refineries

NTPC Limited’s wholly owned subsidiary, NGEL, has entered into a joint venture agreement with Indian Oil Corporation (IOCL) to develop renewable energy projects that can meet round-the-clock power requirements to meet the...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
Constant Climate-Centric Funding Can Limit Global Temperature Under 1.5°C 

Financial support from developed economies to developing nations which is a critical enabler of climate action has been inadequate, said scientists in the latest Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) report...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
India Voices Concern over Europe’s Carbon Tariff Measure at WTO

India has expressed concern about the carbon border measures proposed by the European Union (EU) at a recent meeting of the World Trade Organization’s (WTO) Committee on Trade and Environment. Presenting a paper on the increasing...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
JSW and Greenko Win Karnataka’s Bid for 1 GW of Pumped Storage Projects

JSW Neo Energy (JSW Energy) and Greenko KA 01 IREP (Greenko) have won the Power Company of Karnataka’s (PCKL) auction to supply 1 GW of energy for 8 hours daily from pumped hydro storage projects providing continuous 5-hour...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
Sterling and Wilson Bags BoS Package Tender for 1.2 GW Solar Projects

Sterling and Wilson Renewable Energy, the solar engineering, procurement, and construction (EPC) arm of Shapoorji Pallonji Group, won NTPC’s tender for the balance of system (BOS) package to develop 1.2 GW (4*300 MW) of solar...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
Indian Oil Floats O&M Tender for 8 MW Solar Project in Ahmedabad

Indian Oil Corporation (IOCL) has invited bids for the operation and maintenance (O&M) of an existing 8 MW solar power project at the LPG bottling plant at Sanand in Ahmedabad for five years. The last date to submit the bids...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
IIT Mandi Creates Low-Cost Method for Solar Cell Metal Oxide Layers

Researchers at the Indian Institute of Technology Mandi (IIT Mandi) have claimed a breakthrough in producing metal oxide layers for use in advanced architecture silicon solar cells using a cost-effective method. This innovative...

March 21, 2023

thumbnail
Government Allows NTPC to Invest Over 30% of Net Worth in its Green Arm

The government has allowed NTPC to invest in its subsidiary, NTPC Green Energy (NGEL), beyond the limit allowed for a ‘maharatna’ central public sector enterprise (CPSE). The extant guidelines prescribe a ceiling of 30% of a...

March 21, 2023

MORE NEWS